Showing posts with label heart rate monitor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label heart rate monitor. Show all posts

Monday, November 22, 2010

A power meter for Christmas?

If you are like most people, you probably look for new gadgets and when you see one that you like, you go out and buy it regardless of whether you need it or not. You also probably do not worry about whether it is helpful or practical. I suspect many people who end up with heart rate monitors and power meters fall into this category. I can certainly plead guilty in this matter. Perhaps my only redeeming value here is a vaguely scientifically motivated interest in human performance.

I certainly claimed such interest when I bought my first heart rate monitor 20 years ago. I was curious to see what it would reveal about my rides and my conditioning. To wit, I never really thought of it as a training device and hence I never bought any books entitled Racing with a Heart Rate Monitor or  Racing and Training with a Heart Rate Monitor. I simply set out to record my heart rate under various conditions and to interpret the results. I stayed away from Zones, remembering a previous bad experience in photography.

Pretty soon I discovered two things: 1. That I could accurately predict my heart rate in most conditions; and 2. That my heart rate did not contain much new information beyond what I already knew. These may sound similar but are in fact different. The first means I quickly learned to associate a number with a certain feeling of stress or perceived exertion. The second is no different from the statement I heard at the power clinic in San Diego, "Heart rate is always at a max for the entire duration of this workout." I found out that when I worked really hard, my heart rate was at maximum aerobic. When I went above I immediately felt like I wasn't going to be able to hold it, and sure enough, my heart rate went up and up and I had to stop.

More or less the same thing happened when I bought my first power meter. Only this time I was smart enough to wait for a sponsored team discount. I had learned my lesson: gadgets like these are fun, but they aren't much use so get them cheap.

While the gadgets do not have much information, there is a reason why coaches like them: they provide hard data as evidence that you followed the prescriptions. The data shows you worked out and that you worked out as prescribed. Most cyclists don't have enough computer skills to fake a power output file. But most cyclists can easily deceive a coach who relies on perceived exertion and coaches know that.

It is a steep price to pay for a device that does nothing more than provide evidence of acting in good faith, but that is not the coaches' problem. It is not even unique to coaching. The very same problem occurs in medicine and doctors too make you spend a lot of money to prove that you did as prescribed. Many tests have just the same value: they tell the doctor you followed orders.
A plot like this is often shown to demonstrate the superiority of a power meter. It is deceptive.

In that sense the heart rate monitor is no different.  You may ask, why do cycling coaches ignore it? They do, because they can measure power, a more objective data stream. A heart rate monitor tells you how hard you worked, but if you have a power meter and you know how hard a person can work, you don't need the heart rate monitor because you already know how hard they worked by looking at the power file. If you are a running coach however, then heart rate is your only option.

How about power profiles, quadrant analysis, etc? The short answer is, these things are interesting from a research perspective. Furthermore they can show you things that you may not have thought about or that are not immediately obvious -but not things you can't find out otherwise!

However, just like any diagnostic, knowing more does not mean you can do more. You may have heard this joke about doctors: Internists know everything but they can do nothing, surgeons don't know anything but they can do everything, psychiatrists don't known anything and they can't do anything, and finally pathologists know everything and can do everything but they are always 24 hrs late. Although the joke pokes fun at how little medicine can do for you, one thing is a key part: knowing about something does not mean you can fix it.

You may know your power profile, or look at your quadrant analysis and see issues. But there is little evidence you can correct them even with "special exercises." There is not even enough evidence to say you should correct what you perceive as deficits or that doing so is even beneficial. But like medicine, that has not stopped practitioners from trying hard.

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Technocraze

There is little doubt that we in the Western world have grown addicted to consuming technology. In 2005, the US alone generated 2.6 million tons of e-waste. It is the fastest growing waste stream in the civilized world. We don't see it because most of it gets shipped to China. In some sense that is befitting since most of the gadgets we buy come from there originally.

e-waste

Gadgets dominate our lives and not always for the better. Deadly car accidents due to cell phones and texting have already taken up all the gains from enforcing DIU laws and then some. More people are being robbed and attacked because they are distracted by their cellphones than benefit from having a phone handy in an emergency. Gadgets are also a very expensive addiction on par with narcotics or other illegal substances.

I have to admit that I used to be an early adopter of all things electronic. I sold my record collection and switched to CD's before most record stores in Europe started selling CDs. That also coincided with my move to the US and since the US was lagging considerably in this matter, I had the hardest time finding music for many years.

One of the things that attracted me to cycling was technology and I quickly amassed enough gadgets to fill a small research lab. I bought one of the earliest heart rate monitors with a computer interface. At that time, the computer interface was bulky and cost more than the watch, which wasn't cheap either. Every time I rode I faithfully downloaded my data to the computer. It helped that I was working at a defense lab where computers were easy to access because at the time PC's were not common. I also sported one of the first laptops and lugged it around all over the world. I remember that many people looked at me with envy but they did not have to carry the box.

Years later I was one of the first to buy a power meter. And then a GPS. Not too long afterwards however, I started having second thoughts about gadgetry in everyday life. Not only was I getting tired of lugging stuff around, keeping it all charged, and downloading all the data, I quickly found that the data I collected were highly repetitive and devoid of new information.

Although lack of usefulness was not the main reason at the time, it did matter. Whatever the reason, I am happy to say that I am the most gadget-free rider out there. I don't even bother to install a speedometer any more.  As John Cobb once told me: "Why do you need a speedometer? As long as there is someone in front of you, you are not going fast enough."
My hitech Cockpit
More hitech cockpits

While I do not doubt the value of measuring devices such as heart rate monitors, power meters, and wind tunnels for those engaged in the quest for new knowledge, I think that their usefulness for everyday riders, and even pro cyclists, is not there. I would go further and say that in many cases these items become distractions that do at least as much harm as good -the good being next to zero in any case.

When you have a heart rate monitor or a power meter you quickly learn that after a short period of time, it becomes trivial for you to guess your heart rate or power output. These things do not change much and you can quickly develop a good estimate of your output. I used to be able to overlay my heart rate charts from all my Monday rides, all my Tuesday rides, etc. -we rode the same rides every week in my team- and they matched perfectly. 


If anything these items can become very limiting. If you rely on your power meter to tell you what you can do (i.e. to pace yourself) you could be limiting yourself. That too was said more than a few times at that same clinic -all the while showing that one of the uses of the power meter is to pace oneself.

The truth is that if you need a power meter to pace yourself, you probably also need a GPS to drive to the corner grocery store or a cellphone to keep track of your friends. If that is the case you will always lose out to those who can use their brain. It is the perfect low maintenance, low cost, supercomputer and it can run circles around those high tech contraptions. Furthermore, it is always there as long as you are.

Tuesday, July 22, 2008

Gadgets

In the early days of cycle computers you would buy a small device that read out speed, average speed, distance, and possibly cadence. Why people wanted cadence was always beyond me but that is another matter. One thing about those early devices -Avocet was a major brand then- was that they were easy to install, reliable, and had a very long battery life. They were essentially trouble-free. You installed them and you did not need to worry about them for at least another year or two. 

The data from these computers was accurate and reproducible. It was also useful and easy to interpret. However, as time went by companies saw the potential to increase their profits by adding more data, more storage, more features, and more "analysis." Today's cycle computers are overstuffed toys, full of unnecessary functions. These toys are also overly expensive, but provide little value other than entertainment. All come with often overlooked but major hidden costs.

The devices are tricky to install and tricky to use; they are often unreliable and work poorly under real life conditions; the data is frequently lacking or inaccurate and even more frequently not reproducible. Many functions are based on formulas or lookup tables and may not apply to you. And worst of all, battery life is just about non-existent. You are lucky if the device has enough juice for one long ride. Some GPS devices die within six hours.

The new gadgets also have several readouts leading some people to switch between screens instead of paying attention to the road. I have personally witnessed several accidents where riders hit the deck because they were fiddling with their cycle computers. Not only is there a data overload, most devices also suffer from very poor interface design. We may have to wait until Steve Jobs turns his attention to the cycle computer before things will change.

Newer gadgets also allow the user to download values. This ensures hours of additional wasteful  entertainment. Given the poor quality of the recorded data, one wonders how useful analysis can be. Some device makers are apparently aware of this problem and they sneakily "correct" the data coming from your gadget. In most cases they do so without warning you or without giving you the option to disable the "feature." Nearly all download programs smooth the data. Smoothing can be helpful but in many instances it is the instantaneous changes that have the highest information content. However, given the noisy nature of the data, it is probably just as well that these are smoothed out.

Some companies go even further. Most GPS devices will correct your recorded position when it happens to lie in the scenery instead of on the road. One can argue that this is a good thing. But what does it tell you about your speed or distance? If these are "corrected" too, then what did your expensive gadget really do for you?

One of the first "hot" features added was the altimeter. Altimeters work with pressure sensors that need to be nulled before every ride. Unless you are a airline pilot with access to air traffic control, that is easier said than done. Blame the interface, or the complex routine needed to reset the device; or the difficulty of finding out what the barometric pressure is at the time of the ride. Whatever the reason, the fact is that most people don't bother resetting their altimeters before a ride. What that means is that their data are off by a sizable margin. Never mind the temperature sensitivity. As the ride progresses and the temperature changes -quite common on the California coast- the meter starts drifting over time, making all readings completely useless. 

While most cyclists are aware of these problems, few seem to care.

It gets even better when you add a heart rate monitor. Not only can you pick up other people's readings unless you have a coded transmitter, you can also skip beats or record extra beats due to poor connections. The efficiency changes with skin moisture and can fail with no sweat or too much sweat. Movement of the strap can easily cause artifacts or missed readouts and many devices pickup EMG signals from the chest muscles. The latter is much more of a problem for runners who move their arms than for cyclists who often sit quite still. Even so, about half the time your readout is incorrect or unreliable for one reason or another. And it happens more frequently when you go hard. Needless to say that is also the time when the information is most valuable.

Once again experience shows that most users are aware of the problems but that does not seem to affect their enthusiasm for using the device. Nearly everyone I have talked to told me their heart rate monitor does not work properly from time to time. All have learned to ignore very low or very high readings, and most have developed some "intuition" for correct readouts.

Heart rate monitors have alarms to alert you when you cross a preset threshold. It is quite common to run by someone whose heart rate monitor is acting up and beeping furiously. Much like the neighborhood car alarm that everyone ignores, the owner of the device has long since stopped paying attention to the beeps. But he or she still uses the device in every race.

Ultimately the real problem here is not that devices give random incorrect readings. When used properly these tools can be quite informative. The trouble is that most people don't take the time to learn to use them properly. But they still rely on the "information" or defer to the meter. And in the process they no longer pay attention to their body.

Listening to your body is one of the most valuable skills you can develop as an endurance athlete. And one of the best ways to do so is to train without gadgets. Save the devices for a few tests that you can use to track your progress on a regular basis. At other times, you are better off with just a plain old wired speedometer. It will save weight and batteries too.